Knowledge
Comparison table DIN EN ISO 9001, QS-9000, VDA 6.1, ISO/TS 16949
QM system requirements: comparison between DIN EN ISO 9000:1994, QS-9000, VDA 6.1 and ISO/TS 16949:1999
| Element DIN EN ISO 9001 | DIN EN ISO 9001 | QS-9000 (Section I) | VDA 6, Part 1 | ISO/TS 16949 compared with QS 9000 and VDA 6.1 |
| 4.1 Management responsibility | Purpose: to define and practise quality as part of corporate policy and as a management task. Quality policy Organisation Resources Management representative Management review | In addition: Organisational interfaces must be documented. Higher requirements for management with regard to its supervisory duty. TQM techniques are required. Section II.2 contains requirements for continuous improvement. Requirements for customer satisfaction are listed. | In addition: The continuous improvement process is also required. Higher requirements for management with regard to its supervisory duty. TQM techniques are required. Requirements for customer and employee satisfaction are listed. | Stronger emphasis on focusing on continuous quality improvement. The quality policy must define objectives with metrics and include continuous improvement of quality, service, cost and technology (4.1.1.4). Personnel responsible for quality must have the authority to stop production (4.1.2.1.3). Evidence of personnel responsible for quality on all shifts must be available (4.1.2.2.2). Personnel responsible for quality must be present on all shifts (4.1.2.2.2). The management system review must include continuous improvement of all elements and an assessment of quality objectives and quality-related losses. Cross-company comparison must be taken into account as part of benchmarking. An information system that provides early information on product data in the use phase is intended to promote the trend towards external comparison (4.1.5). Involvement and motivation of employees, promotion of quality awareness and consideration of product safety aspects, especially in design and process control, are required (4.1.7.1). A process for compliance with governmental safety and environmental regulations must be demonstrated and ensured (4.1.7.2). |
| 4.2 Quality management system | Purpose: to document and maintain the quality management system. General QM procedure Defining and documenting quality planning • Selecting a suitable structure for the QM procedures that fits the company's working method (note: the QM plans may take the form of a reference to the appropriate procedures). | In addition: Risk assessment methods and inspection plans are required. Use of various QM tools such as APQP and FMEA. | In addition: Customer requirements for the product and the QM system are strongly incorporated. QM plans and inspection sequence plans are required. | If project management techniques are used in the product development process, a project manager and a project team must be appointed (4.2.4.1). As part of the product development process, metrics must be defined, results evaluated and actions specified (4.2.4.3). A cross-functional approach must be chosen that includes the following points: special characteristics, FMEA and control plans (4.2.4.4 and 4.2.4.7). Process capability evidence must be provided and additional process control requirements determined, the results of which must be documented. The documentation must contain targets (marked with the customer's symbol where specified by the customer) for process capability, reliability, maintainability and availability as well as acceptance criteria (4.2.4.5). Within the scope of CAD, the company must be able to use computer-aided methods for producing production tooling or prototypes (4.2.4.6). The element of process development management gives rise to new obligations to introduce procedures for the development and verification of production processes (4.2.4.9). For control plans, the recommendation to develop them on an interdisciplinary basis has become an obligation. The predefined reaction plans must be able to be triggered when required (4.2.4.10). The approval of production processes and products must also be applied to suppliers. If requested by the customer, requirements for the verification/identification of e.g. new models must also be met (4.2.4.11). Tooling management has been supplemented with additional requirements for documentation of changes (4.2.6). Continuous improvement must also take special characteristics into account, for which a prioritised action plan must be developed (4.2.7). The performance of the quality management system must be evaluated in relation to the quality policy, the business plan and customer satisfaction (4.2.8) |
| 4.3 Contract review | Purpose: to avoid errors at the customer/supplier interface. • Before submitting an offer/contract review, check the offer and order acceptance for: • Defining procedures for contract amendments • Preparing and keeping records of contract reviews | In addition: Marketing must be addressed more intensively, the entire process must be described in more detail (important: take customer requirements and specifications into account). | A procedure for documenting costs and prices when preparing offers must be in place. It must also be ensured that customer requirements are met (4.3.2.2). | |
| 4.4 Design control | Purpose: a procedure for verifying the product design is introduced and maintained to ensure that the specified quality requirements are met | In addition: Higher requirements for methods to be applied and for planning and documentation of data (use of IT). The customer participates actively. | In addition: Higher requirements for methods to be applied and for planning and documentation of data (use of IT). | The company must explicitly demonstrate and ensure that the design team is qualified to meet the design requirements (4.4.2.2) and must have access to research and development facilities to ensure product and process innovation (4.4.2.3). Design inputs must include targets for product life, reliability, durability and maintainability (4.4.4.2). Competitive aspects must be gathered for future projects and competitive analyses applied (4.4.4.3). The company must consider the effects of a design change on other products and systems (4.4.9.2). |
| 4.5 Document control | Purpose: to provide valid, checked and approved documents in good time where they are needed and to withdraw invalid documents. Approval and issue • Issuing/distributing new and/or updated documents • Defining procedures for managing QM documents (lists etc.) Changes/modifications • Identifying the nature of the change • Checking and approving changed documents • Providing information on the current revision status of documents | In addition: Higher requirements for document management. Customer specifications are also controlled as documents. | In addition: Higher requirements for document management. Requirements regarding the implementation of customer documents. | |
| 4.6 Purchasing | Purpose: to ensure that purchased products meet the specified quality requirements. Evaluation of subcontractors • Keeping records of subcontractor performance • Selecting subcontractors Purchasing data • Preparing the purchasing documents • Checking the purchasing documents for content and adequacy Verification of purchased products | In addition: Higher requirements with regard to approved materials and all legal requirements (hazardous substances). Higher requirements for supplier development and a more precise definition of individual inspection steps are also required. | In addition: Quality requirements for products and services must be addressed. Supplier quality is assured through more precise supplier selection. Furthermore, more precise definitions of individual inspection steps are required. | The company must work towards its suppliers aligning their QM system with TS 16949 (4.6.2.2). |
| 4.7 Customer-supplied product | Purpose: to assure the quality of supplied products (parts provided by the customer or explicitly specified). General • Identifying customer-supplied products • Storing customer-supplied products • Maintaining customer-supplied products • Establishing an information system for lost, damaged or otherwise unusable products • Defining records of the affected products | In addition: The requirements are generally more differentiated and higher (e.g. with regard to agreements on quality measures). | ||
| 4.8 Identification and traceability | Purpose: to introduce and maintain procedures for unambiguous assignment of the product, avoid mix-ups, enable subsequent clarification and ensure traceability (if required). General • Identifying products for internal purposes • Recording the identification in the documents • Deciding on the need for traceability • if required: suitable (unambiguous) identification of products/lots/batches for traceability reasons | In addition: The requirements are generally more differentiated and higher (e.g. with regard to identification of products for internal processes). | ||
| 4.9 Process control | Purpose: to plan, define and monitor production and assembly processes. To ensure that the processes run under controlled conditions. General • Creating work instructions with work criteria for all processes and activities • Defining and providing suitable production equipment and working conditions • Approving equipment and processes • Monitoring process characteristics • Carrying out in-process inspections Special processes • Creating procedures for special processes • Qualifying/approving the special processes • Monitoring the special processes • Creating qualified records of special processes • Keeping records of personnel qualifications | In addition: Requirement to demonstrate process data. Safety and environmental regulations must be listed. Section II.3 contains requirements for preventive maintenance. Process capability must be checked. Special production part approval process (PPAP) and release procedure. | In addition: Process development and process data must be documented and evaluated. Approval of process and procedure sequences. Process capability studies must be carried out. The processes must be checked for their effectiveness. | Work instructions must be available for product- and process-related activities so that no work interruptions are necessary (4.9.2). Important process events or machine repairs should be noted on control charts. The company must keep records of the implementation dates of process changes (4.9.3). |
| 4.10 Inspection and testing | Purpose: to demonstrate fulfilment of specified requirements using documented and applied inspection procedures. Incoming inspection • Documenting provisional releases • Planning incoming inspection • Carrying out incoming inspection • Recording inspection results • Ensuring that supplied products cannot be used or processed further without incoming inspection • Defining procedures for handling, controlling and identifying uninspected products (urgent production) • Taking into account documented inspection evidence from the manufacturer Inspection records • Defining and providing documents for inspection record purposes • Defining the rules (who, what, when, how, where ...) when inspection results are recorded as evidence of the required quality | In addition: Inspection processes must be documented more precisely. Cooperation with accredited testing bodies takes place. Already in the area of intermediate inspection, there are requirements for complete and functional testing. | In addition: Inspection processes must be documented more precisely. Requirements regarding a product audit at vehicle manufacturers and suppliers. | External testing laboratories used must meet the requirements of ISO/IEC 17025 (4.10.6). |
| 4.11 Inspection equipment | Purpose: to ensure the suitability of all inspection equipment (not measuring equipment) including software (monitoring, maintenance and identification of the inspection equipment) General • Defining the required accuracy of inspections and selecting suitable inspection equipment • Identifying and calibrating or adjusting inspection equipment and devices (according to recognised national standards) • Introducing, documenting and maintaining calibration procedures • Ensuring the required correctness and accuracy of the inspection equipment • Identification or marking of the inspection equipment (evidence of calibration status) • Keeping records of calibration • Keeping the design documents for self-made inspection equipment • Ensuring suitable environmental conditions for calibrations, inspections and measurements to be carried out • Ensuring the handling, protection and storage of the inspection equipment • Deciding on the procedure when an inspection device is found to be defective • Defining protective measures against changes to possible settings of inspection equipment and calibrations • Keeping the calibration/inspection results • Protecting and storing the inspection equipment | In addition: Measurement system capability and monitoring procedures are required. Additional records for inspection equipment monitoring must be kept. | In addition: The requirements are more differentiated. | Customer-owned inspection equipment must be included in inspection equipment monitoring (4.11.3). |
| 4.12 Inspection status | Purpose: to ensure that only products that have passed all specified inspections can be delivered (including internally). General • Identifying the inspection status by • Ensuring that the inspection status is recognisable in all phases of production • Recording the inspection status in the product records • Identifying finished products | In addition: Requirements regarding spatial arrangement and additional inspections with regard to customer requirements. | ||
| 4.13 Control of nonconforming product | Purpose: to ensure that nonconforming products are prevented from unintended use or installation (control, identification, evaluation, segregation and disposition). General • Identifying and documenting nonconforming products • Segregating and controlling nonconforming products Review and disposition of nonconforming products • Granting concessions • Defining procedures for rejecting products • Defining procedures for reworking products • Defining procedures for destroying/scrapping products • Defining procedures for regrading for other uses • if contractually agreed: reporting the intended use or repair to the customer • Documenting the description of the nonconformity and, where applicable, notification of the customer | In addition: Suspect products are mentioned separately. | In addition: Increased requirements for rework and the detection of recurring defects. | Tracking of corrective actions must be demonstrated. The customer must be notified immediately if nonconforming products have been shipped (4.13.1.3). |
| 4.14 Corrective and preventive action | Purpose: to eliminate causes of defects in order to avoid recurrence; to introduce and maintain procedures for investigating and analysing causes of defects, initiating defect prevention measures, applying monitoring measures and documenting the changes. General • Carrying out and documenting the corrective actions taken for prevention • Evaluating quality records • Analysing all processes, work operations, concessions, records, service reports and customer complaints • Monitoring the implementation and effectiveness of measures to eliminate the causes of defects • Defining, initiating and documenting measures to eliminate the causes of defects • systematic recording of all defects in | In addition: Problem-solving techniques must be described. Rejected products must be investigated. | In addition: Higher requirements regarding causes of defects, risk of defects and recurring defects. | As part of the analysis of returned parts, the company must minimise the analysis time (4.14.2.3). |
| 4.15 Handling, storage, packaging, preservation and delivery | Purpose: to prevent damage to products and impairment of quality. To ensure that all products are handled and stored safely and correctly. Handling • Providing means of transport Storage • Providing suitable storage conditions/storage rooms • Defining and identifying storage areas • Defining procedures for removing goods from storage • Assessing the suitability of storage conditions Packaging • Defining the type of identification • Defining the type of packaging and packaging protection Delivery • Defining the delivery method • Carrying out delivery • Preserving quality until delivery at the destination | In addition: Requirements for inventory, empty containers and production logistics. | In addition: Higher requirements for packaging (packaging errors and transport damage). | Obsolete and superseded products must be controlled (4.15.3.2). In production planning, the company must plan and control production in line with customer requirements (4.15.6.3). |
| 4.16 Control of quality records | Purpose: evidence of the required quality and effectiveness of the QM system. To ensure that all quality records used as evidence of fulfilment of requirements are managed and retained. General • Defining the necessary quality records • Creating procedures for the management and retention of quality records • Defining the retention period of quality records • Retaining quality records • Managing quality records | In addition: Higher requirements for retention periods and for records that remain valid after a model change. | In addition: Generally higher requirements are set. Requirements regarding the evaluation and distribution of quality records and the exchange of quality data. Requirements regarding public accessibility. | |
| 4.17 Internal quality audits | Purpose: evidence that quality assurance is proceeding according to plan and that the QM system is effective. To ensure that procedures for planning and conducting internal quality audits are applied, comparing target and actual states and evaluating the effectiveness of the system. General • Creating and updating the audit plan; creating procedures for conducting internal quality audits • Informing all employees about the purpose of internal quality audits • Selecting and training auditors • Deciding on goods acceptance and storage • Conducting internal quality audits and documenting the results • Evaluating the quality audits • Discussing the results of internal quality audits • Deciding on audits and documenting necessary measures • Monitoring and implementing appropriate corrective actions | In addition: More precise delimitation of the individual requirements. | The company must audit the product development process to determine the effectiveness of these processes (4.17.2.2). Audits must also be carried out in production and during the delivery process. Auditors used must meet the qualifications required by the customer (4.17.3). | |
| 4.18 Training | Purpose: to ensure and maintain sufficient personnel qualification. To introduce procedures for identifying training needs and for conducting and documenting training and qualification measures. General • Identifying training needs • Defining a programme for job-related training and further education measures • Developing and implementing quality motivation measures (TQM) • Creating training plans • Training employees entrusted with quality-relevant activities • Keeping records of training | In addition: Section 3 takes customer-specific requirements into account. Training as a strategic task. | In addition: Requirements are formulated more narrowly and in a more differentiated way, especially with regard to quality training. | Taking into account customer-specific requirements, the effectiveness of training must be reviewed regularly. On-the-job training must be provided on site for all new or modified activities. Employees who influence quality must be informed about the consequences of nonconformities for the customer (4.18.3). |
| 4.19 Servicing | Purpose: to ensure and demonstrate that the contractually agreed servicing meets the specified requirements. To review the requirements for contractually agreed servicing. General • Checking the activities performed for correctness • Creating records • Defining procedures for reporting the results to quality assurance | In addition: Feedback of information from field performance. | In addition: Higher requirements (e.g. operating and installation instructions, early warning system, etc.) | If a service agreement exists, the company must demonstrate the effectiveness of the service, the use of special tools and the training of service personnel (4.19.3). |
| 4.20 Statistical techniques | Purpose: to check and determine the suitability of processes and actual values of product characteristics. To introduce and maintain procedures for appropriate statistical methods. General • Creating procedures for statistical methods | In addition: Basic statistical knowledge must be available throughout the company. Application of SPC | In addition: More precise definition of needs in the individual functions (development, supplies, process control and optimisation, final inspection, field). | |
| not included | not included | Cost considerations | ||
| not included | not included | Product safety |
